Catholic Common Core – Junior Achievement

Okay, so last week my daughter, who is in first grade, came home and said that the mother of one of her classmates came in to talk to them and she showed me this little booklet.

Jr Achievement Book

In it, it talked about people in a community and the things they do to help each other and to take care of the community. I have since learned that this a K-12 entrepreneurship program that is very popular with many parents, but something about it all just irked me.

So I looked up this Junior Achievement organization. Here is what their website says:


Junior Achievement’s Purpose:

Junior Achievement inspires and prepares young people to succeed in a global economy.

Junior Achievement Sparks Student Success

…Our volunteer-delivered, kindergarten-12th grade programs foster work-readiness, entrepreneurship and financial literacy skills, and use experiential learning to inspire students to dream big and reach their potential. With the help of more than 213,000 volunteers, JA students develop the skills they need to experience the realities and opportunities of work and entrepreneurship in the 21st century global marketplace.

Learn about JA’s Blended Learning Transformation

Junior Achievement is incorporating a blended learning approach into its programs, creating a scalable, relevant, and responsive student experience. By blending our current face-to-face approach with digital opportunities to access JA content, we can reach more students in more relevant ways that better accommodate students’ diverse learning styles and provide them with 21st century skills that will equip them to be successful in the global marketplace…


Common Core Buzzword Alert

Blech. Blech. Blah. Let’s play how many CC buzzwords we can find in the above paragraphs:

21st Century
global marketplace
global economy
work-readiness

This program is sold as a way to introduce children, starting in Kindergarten, how to understand wants versus needs and to figure out what kind of job they can do and the skills they will need to develop, or what kind of business they can start that will bring them success. Why is it necessary start this “career readiness” so early on? Besides, don’t students learn about communities, from the local on up to the big wide world, as part of history and social studies? And, since they are in Catholic school, won’t they learn about being helpful neighbors in their community by knowing that Jesus taught us to love our neighbors as ourselves and do unto others as we would have them do unto us?

Maybe I’m just not getting it. Here is a sample of the program from a Catholic school in Rochester, NY.

http://seton.dorschools.org/files/filesystem/JA%20in%20a%20Day%20at%20Seton%20-%20Program%20List.pdf

Everything Is Awesome

According to the Junior Achievement website, “classroom volunteers transform the key concepts of our lessons into a message that inspires and empowers students to believe in themselves, showing them they can make a difference in the world.” It strikes as being philosophically rooted in materialism and brings to mind the ‘Everything is Awesome’ world from the Lego movie.

For Catholic students, in terms of spiritual growth, what does it mean to believe “in yourself?”  What about reinforcing a belief in God and a firm reliance on Him for guidance on how they will “make a difference in the world?”  Do the classroom volunteers interject and remind the children that God willed each one of them into being and that they will finding meaningful work that allows them to provide for themselves and their families while serving God and their fellow man? For Christians, success should be much more than merely finding temporal work. And what about vocations and callings that transcend the “global marketplace” like the priesthood or religious orders and the important role they serve in the community?

One Big Glaring Omission in Jr. Achiever World

Looking at the “Junior Achiever community” above, I see a lot of busy people and a lot of recycling and trash pick up going on, but what I don’t see in the busy Junior Achiever community is a church. Of course, since this is designed for secular education, if they put a church, they would probably have to depict all places of worship on the cover. But, I am not sending my daughter to public school. I am sending her to Catholic school.

And if this program is so valuable to later “success” in this life, why can’t Catholic schools create their own version of this program that incorporates Catholic beliefs, values, and virtues?

My Junior Achiever ‘Dear Mommy’ letter:

This was the little Junior Achievement assignment – a  “Dear Mommy – What I Want or Need letter” my daughter brought home:

Jr. Achievement - What I Want

At least she knew these were “wants” and not “needs.” But, as her parents, we  have already explained these things to her and she already does chores around the house. But for some reason, those of us who are responsible, engaged parents are being subjected to the “schools must also be parents because parents just don’t know” mentality that permeates education nowadays. I did write her back and told her, much to her disappointment, that she is not going to get a horse or a DS for making her bed.

All this aligns very nicely with the Common Core world of “21st century skills” and preparing students for “jobs of the future.” It coordinates with the categorizing and sorting of the units of human capital (that would be the students – our children) to see where they fit as global citizens in a global marketplace.

God Does Not Require That We Be Successful

I recently heard the following quote attributed to Blessed Mother Theresa:

“God does not require that we be successful only that we be faithful.”

And, as Terrence Moore says in his book StoryKillers (which is excellent by the way):

“The man or woman who understands human nature and history, and who has a tolerable work ethic and a sound character, will never have trouble getting into college, nor landing a job, nor gaining a public voice, nor knowing what counts for truth, beauty, and goodness in the world. As such, that man or women will have a much greater chance of obtaining the great end of human life: happiness — the happiness that comes from pursuing truth and living virtuously.”

Advertisements

Happy St. Patrick’s Day – Update

St. Patrick’s Day Activities

Well, as I had feared, below are photos of some of the St. Patrick’s Day “busy work” my daughter came home with … from Catholic school. I really feel like quite a curmudgeon for nitpicking all this stuff. I guess my expectations were a little high for our “modern” Catholic education system.

NONE of the work she came home with referenced St. Patrick or the story/legend of how he used the clover as a symbol of the Holy Trinity, or any of the symbolism in the renderings of St. Patrick, such as his staff and the snakes. I asked and she said they did learn about “St. Patrick” but that she just couldn’t remember what they did. I have no doubt that Saint Patrick was indeed discussed. The attention span of a first grader is short lived to be sure. But what will she remember more, St. Patrick or leprechauns, four leaf clovers & pots of gold? Of course, I made sure to reinforce what I knew about Saint Patrick and we did some activities at home.

I certainly don’t think there is anything terribly wrong with hearing about mischievous little leprechuans and the Irish fairy tales based on them, but I just expected so much more in sending her to Catholic school where we can actually talk about the Saints instead of using pagan customs and modern traditions that were established so that these religious holidays could also be celebrated by those who do not wish to acknowledge anything religious but still participate in them. Focussing on leprechuans is like diverting attention from the true meaning of Easter and Chrismas by making it about visits from Easter Bunny and Santa Claus.

I thought Catholic school would be where instead of writing an “acrostic poem” about being lucky, she would copy down a verse from Hail, Glorious St. Patrick! But alas, modernism has crept into our Catholic schools where some teachers (but certainly by no means all) don’t even seem to look to Catholic resources for classroom materials.

The worksheets pictured below came from www.abcteach.com. So I went to the site to see what choices they offered for classroom activites to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day. None of the activities referenced or even mention Saint Patrick (except for using his name to describe the day) or anything Catholic for that matter.

If I mention it, they will say they are just trying to make things fun for the children as if children could not possibly understand or appreciate the lives of the Saints. And even if they are a little bored, so what. Aren’t we supposed to educating future saints here?

Here are some of the activities she did in school:

There was an activity about the Irish flag, Celtic musicians, and an information sheet on the origins of the harp, with the only “religious” reference being “The harp is at least as old as the Bible.”

Wearin’ Of the Green

St. Pattys Coloring Page - Lephrechau

Complete the Story

And they had this little story assignment about the life of St. Patrick .. oops, I mean about leprechauns, gold, and shamrocks …

St Pattys Day - Story Page

Lucky Shamrock

She also colored a lovely pink shamrock and wrote an acrostic poem about being lucky.

St Patrick's Day - Lucky clover

One of My Activities

For our own activity here at home, I had printed off this activity from the awesome website http://www.catholicinspired.com. I also did the mobile pictured below. The child cuts and pastes the beautiful and inspiring images of God, Jesus & the dove (Holy Spirit) onto the shamrock to represent the Holy Trinity, three in One.

from www.catholicinspired.com
from http://www.catholicinspired.com

Compare & Contrast

Just to “compare and contrast” (a favorite Common Core language arts technique) – here are two St. Patrick’s Day craft activites that involve making a mobile:

This one from abcteach.com:

Source: http://www.abcteach.com/documents/craft-st-patricks-day-mobile-primary-18596
Source: http://www.abcteach.com/documents/craft-st-patricks-day-mobile-primary-18596

And this one from http://www.catholicinspired.com:

Source: http://www.catholicinspired.com/2015/03/st-patrick-mobile-color-cut-glue-and.html
Source: http://www.catholicinspired.com/2015/03/st-patrick-mobile-color-cut-glue-and.html

Which one is more inspiring and reverent of the true meaning of St. Patrick’s day? Which one would you expect to find in a Catholic school?


Saint Patrick, Pray for us.